Skip to content

Nagin, the McAlary’s and FEMA Trailers

May 20, 2010

I find myself in a rather surreal position these days. I have been reading words written during the time period Treme is depicting, thousands of them, for weeks now, as part of another project. I was also here during that time. Now I’m watching it on my TV every Sunday night.

This week, in a very busy episode, Simon and the guys got me several different ways. I couldn’t decide which thread to write about as they were all viable, so have decided to do little snippets on each of them.

First up: Ray Nagin

In reading all the words these weeks, I’ve noticed over and over again references to Nagin as Hero. Stemming from his radio interview shortly after the storm, most of us were thrilled that our Mayor was saying what needed, in our opinion, to be said. He was cussing on the radio, pulling no punches, people were dying, we needed help. Oh yeah. We loved it. I heard from two writers this week whose work I’ve been reading. Both were concerned that pieces I chose included laudatory comments about Nagin. They asked if they could remove them. One guy wrote that in Alabama there were evacuees holding up signs for the press that said, “Viva Nagin.” Another writer had written, “Nagin for President.” In our household we had jumped up and down screaming and hugging when we heard that radio interview. Finally, finally, someone had said what needed to be said. We weren’t the only ones who felt that way. On Treme this week, Nagin was skewered, becoming a, um, self-pleasuring papier mache effigy. Please remember that the series is now around about January/February of 2006–a mere five months after that interview.

How did he go from hero to hated? Lies, inaction, divisiveness, that’s how. As it turns out there was also a mighty large dollop of corruption mixed in with all that, but at the time we didn’t know that. We only knew that we felt let down. We were hurt. We were very, very angry. Yeah, we were pissed at the Feds, and Bush/Cheney in particular, we were pissed at the State, Madam Governor will you please quit equivocating, and we were pissed that the guy we thought would be the one to fight for us, for our City, turned out to be a peacock who really liked the color green and didn’t really give a hoot about human colors, black or white–regardless of his polarizing chocolate city remark. We were defending ourselves in the national media, defending our right to exist as a city, our right to rebuild, frantically typing facts against “below sea level” bullshit in comments sections all over the nation, and the one guy we thought was with us on our side of the barricade was actually on the beaches of Jamaica looking at real estate ads for homes in Dallas. (Quick aside: Loved Toni’s phone conversation with Creighton on the way to Port Arthur: “YOU swore a solemn oath. I didn’t.”) We felt utterly betrayed. Yup. All that happened in those five months. Nagin as a KdV float has pretty much been standard ever since.

Next up: The McAlary Family

The Treme writing team did a great job showing the disparity of conditions here at that time. The McAlary family, obviously well to do, are having martinis in their unwatermarked, perfectly furnished, unblemished parlor. Only sunlight and intact paintings and upholstery are seen through their un-boarded up windows. Truth is they probably had a couple of Blackwater’s hired guns sitting on their porch during the darkest days. They no doubt hired someone to get rid of any unsightly and annoying tree branches that may have been broken in the storm. They are not talking about insurance adjusters or FEMA. They were covered in every conceivable way. The storm has had very little effect on them. Their conversation with Davis, pointing out their strong ties to the Confederacy, is marvelous. His saying that he usually tells people he was named for Miles, Sammy, Ossie or Angela was hilarious and his “veiled racist” statement was far more restrained than my response was to comments about “that element” now being gone from the city. I heard similar sentiments from my own not-from-NOLA family and I came unglued. That element. Last week Davis got punched out for using the N word. No one punches Mr. Perlis-wearing McAlary for sitting mum as his wife, pinky raised, says those words: Code for black people, black neighborhoods, all filled with criminals and drug addicts and welfare queens. Davis’ family has a bottle of Jim Crow right next to the Jim Beam on their bar.

Meanwhile on Miro Street, Big Chief Albert is cutting and sewing in a barely lit, empty but for tables and supplies, bar where he is living with several other men. None have a place to live. Vans and cots in a bar are their only choices. The number of men living with Albert keeps growing. The Feds won’t open the projects (from the McAlarys’ point of view the best news EVER) and those who had homes, like Albert himself, will have to wait for the insurance company’s pennies on the actual dollar value checks (should that actually come through), FEMA, gutting, stud drying and mold deterrent application (a process that takes months, I might add) before they can even think of putting in new drywall. Nevermind the various plans that were bandied about back then. You might get to come home if your zipcode happens to be printed on the piece of paper they pulled out of the hat last night. You might get to stay if after the latest plan is accepted your neighborhood is considered “viable.” Next year it might not be considered viable. Roll the dice. You might have to re-do any rebuilding you already did if they decide that your house has to be raised. Oh yeah. Didn’t tell ya? Insurance which already screwed ya isn’t going to pay for the raising. There were raging arguments about the use of the word “refugee.” I wrote a piece sometime back then defending its use, as opposed to “evacuee.” I got emails. Lots of emails calling me lots of names for using the term refugee, but when all was said and done, the guys on Miro Street are for all intents and purposes refugees. Albert saying that they were making it impossible for “folks” to come back: folks being his own code word, and that he felt like a refugee in his own country was absolutely right on. The Lambreaux clan and the McAlary clan are having very different experiences only a few miles apart in the same city.

And finally: FEMA Trailers

Antoine with the stripper asks how she got a trailer so fast. The answer is obvious. City official’s assistant comes to the bar and tells Albert that the official pulled some strings and got, wait for it, ONE FEMA trailer. Nothing he can do about housing, it’s the Feds issue to deal with. Only one trailer. Take it or leave it. After the storm there were some great ideas for housing, including something called a Katrina Cottage. These were basically modular homes that would be permanently installed on the property where your house used to stand. They would be tricked out a bit so that they would fit in with existing architecture. They were cheaper than FEMA trailers. FEMA said no can do. Stafford Act. FEMA can pay for nothing permanent, no infrastructure, no Katrina cottages, nothing permanent even if it was more cost effective and humane. So instead they bought the formaldehyde exuding trailers. Thousands of them. Nearly 40,000 of them died a useless death in Arkansas after sinking into the mud there. Millions of dollars wasted and 40K families still waiting to come home. There were also arguments about where to put the trailers with 50% of the parishes outside Orleans saying no to any FEMA trailer set up sites as they were afraid they would become permanent like some did in Florida years ago.

While the rest of the country had gone on about their business, these issues were real here. I remember being astonished when I finally saw a FEMA trailer. It wasn’t an apparition but it certainly was a rarity at that time, and I had no idea they were so small. A friend of mine who is an elementary school teacher knew entire families of two or three adults and several children all sharing ONE FEMA trailer. Albert’s astonishment and disgust was the only reasonable reaction to the housing debacle. I’m expecting that story line to develop well. I can see the militance in his face.

These guys have the big issues nailed dead to rights. I actually had to re-read some of my old pieces to remember the numbers and some of the issues. Clearly the writers have some killer researchers. This episode was rich with portent. I only wish they hadn’t rushed through the first few months as fast as they did, bypassing the holidays almost entirely as the holidays of 2005 were tough stuff. But I figure they didn’t know they’d be picked up for another season and were trying to get as much into 13 episodes as they could, if that was all that it was gonna be. I am looking forward to the watching the development of these story lines as so far, these guys are diving into the deep water with their eyes open wide.

  1. May 20, 2010 6:51 pm

    It’s funny, I just sent a note to one of your fellow bloggers (Ray), to ask him – “when did Nagin stop being the voice of the city and turn into the goat?”

    I was watching on the side lines – and blogging about it – when Nagin gave that first big interview in September. And then I lost track of Nagin, and had no clue when or why he went from the Howard Beale of New Orleans to someone widely considered a great big useless dick.

    This is more or less exactly the answer I wanted (more or less the same thing Ray said); it exactly answered that question.

  2. doctorj2u permalink
    May 20, 2010 7:13 pm

    I once supported Nagin. I loved his rant to WWL radio. I remember making excuses for his words in the “chocolate city” episode. Maybe he meant like dark chocolate and white milk – a mixture? At some point Nagin checked out. At first I decided he had PTSD. Later the anger just settled into hating him. No one was the voice of New Orleans . We were on our own.
    I have one nitpick with your essay Sam. The people of Uptown, (Sliver on the River), even the Garden District, suffered greatly from the storm. They have businesses, you know. I know people seriously worried if they should just chuck it in and move to North Carolina away from all the problems of a struggling New Orleans. No, this does not equal the problems faced by those that had no money to fall back on. But these were deep worries for all that had their lives destroyed by the fallen levees. The hurt is the same. I have seen it from all classes and all incomes.

  3. brueso permalink
    May 20, 2010 11:12 pm

    you said = trying to ‘make it all fit in 13 episodes- you do know there’s only 10 this season, right?

  4. rickngentilly permalink
    May 21, 2010 2:05 am

    doc thats pretty much the time line.

    the chocolate city speech was cool with me.

    it was after that that i quit apologizing for him in public.

    it took a little more time for me to realize he had checked out.

    the stone age contract , the ban on “mexicans” speach , the casinos up and down tulane ave. fantasy.

    the man was in full bullshit mode at that point.

    it was only because of the nola bloggers that the commen man could keep up with his b.s.

    the times picayune and gambit totally hunted and pecked their stories about the mayor.

    the nola bloggers attacked it from every angle and gave the average citizen a place to distill info.

    wist 690 a.m. was also in that number , but not so much lately.

  5. rickngentilly permalink
    May 21, 2010 2:09 am

    what was your take?

    i still play the wwl speech from time to time.

    it was good medicine .

  6. rickngentilly permalink
    May 21, 2010 2:23 am

    re: katrina cottages.

    they were / are just trailors with fancy frosting.

    one of the few good things to come out of our citys stagnation post katrina.

  7. rickngentilly permalink
    May 21, 2010 2:33 am

    one more comment. the reason i got to rehab my house in gentilly before the power came back on was i was living and working at a hotel that was housing 212 blackwater dudes.

    got some good stories about them dudes.

  8. samjasper permalink
    May 21, 2010 9:16 am

    You’re right, drj. I wrote a lot about the plight of local businesses. It was devastating. Just in the Quarter I had two stories I remember: One was about a bar that pre-storm was filled to the rafters pretty much every night, certainly on weekends. Their rent was something way out there like 60K a month, but before the storm they brought in 13K a DAY, so it was not a problem. After the storm, for months and months after the storm, they were lucky if they brought in 700/day. Amazingly they survived. However, some didn’t. A friend owned an R & B club on Bourbon. Again, a place that was usually packed. His rent was 20K a month. He held on for months but finally had to let it go. And it wasn’t just bars and clubs. Shops, medical practices (hard to keep a practice going if all your patients are in Atlanta or Houston), pretty much any other business you can imagine was struggling. There was a huge push during the Xmas season to buy local to keep our small businesses in business.

    Mostly I was trying to contrast the living conditions and attitudes that the writers showed. Not all people from Uptown or even the Garden District are like the McAlary’s, but the writers did a great job of showing the disconnect.

  9. virgotex permalink*
    May 21, 2010 11:35 am

    Another thing about this ep- ya’ll can vouch or not for it’s verity. Until I watched it the third time it din’t hit me how many of the characters were mentioned or shown to be either physically or mentally ill. Sonny, Annie (yes, she’s mentally ill), LaDonna’s mother, Creighton, Antoine, Deacon, the shell-shocked young cop, and possibly Janette- who at the very least is stressed as hell. That’s in one episode

  10. May 21, 2010 12:04 pm

    “Ain’t we all,” as Antoine said to Ms. Catherine.

  11. Bdaggerbones permalink
    May 21, 2010 1:57 pm

    You are mistaken when you refer to Katrina Cottages as “trailers with fancy frosting.” Read this and you will see what I mean.
    Keep in mind, also, that when winds exceed 60 mph ( as in a tropical storm) people are advised to LEAVE their FEMA trailers, while Katrina Cottages are built to withstand winds up to 140 mph. That’s more than just “fancy frosting.”

  12. le blocc permalink
    May 21, 2010 3:01 pm

    you’re apostrophe’s are out of control


  1. Music Of Treme News Roundup – May 21, 2010

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: